1 (edited by robert.schuster 2013-09-12 19:32:17)

Topic: Whislist for migration to iRedAdmin-Pro (MySql)

I'm going eventually to replace my current mailserver solution (free version of mailcleaner; mailcleaner.org) with iRedAdmin-Pro for MySQL backend, but missing a few features:

per domain configurable smtp-callout to an another system (if the domain is forwarded to another host)

per user/domain/server configurable archiving method which sends the messages without any adresschanges to another host:port
just like it is possible with amavisd for the whole server:

$archive_quarantine_method = 'smtp:[212.79.184.19]:2500'; #
# $archive_quarantine_to = 'archive-quarantine'; # rewrite local part of recipient address 
$archive_quarantine_to = '%a'; # keep recipient address
@archive_quarantine_to_maps = (\$archive_quarantine_to);
$mailfrom_to_quarantine = undef;  # undef keeps original sender

per user/domain/server configurable spam/quarantine reporting (with configurable mail teplates) and an user interface to release such messages

one button (and cmd) backup/restore for configuration and/or content to activate an already prepared standby system in a very short time

domain-aliases
customer has several domains which all have the same settings and are all forwarded to the same mailbox server (i.e. ms-exchange)

2

Re: Whislist for migration to iRedAdmin-Pro (MySql)

robert.schuster wrote:

per domain configurable smtp-callout to an another system (if the domain is forwarded to another host)

Sorry, what do you mean "smtp-callout"?

robert.schuster wrote:

per user/domain/server configurable archiving method which sends the messages without any adresschanges to another host:port
just like it is possible with amavisd for the whole server:

$archive_quarantine_method = 'smtp:[212.79.184.19]:2500'; #
# $archive_quarantine_to = 'archive-quarantine'; # rewrite local part of recipient address 
$archive_quarantine_to = '%a'; # keep recipient address
@archive_quarantine_to_maps = (\$archive_quarantine_to);
$mailfrom_to_quarantine = undef;  # undef keeps original sender

If this works for you on old server, it should work on iRedMail.

robert.schuster wrote:

per user/domain/server configurable spam/quarantine reporting (with configurable mail teplates) and an user interface to release such messages

It's server-wide configuration, not per-user/domain. You can release or delete quarantined mails with iRedAdmin-Pro (only domain admin can do this).

robert.schuster wrote:

one button (and cmd) backup/restore for configuration and/or content to activate an already prepared standby system in a very short time

With iRedMail, you don't need to backup/restore config files of Postfix/Amavisd/Dovecot/etc, just backup your mailboxes, mail accounts (and SQL databases), then re-install iRedMail and restore them.

robert.schuster wrote:

domain-aliases
customer has several domains which all have the same settings and are all forwarded to the same mailbox server (i.e. ms-exchange)

Supported.

I suggest trying to setup an iRedMail server on virtual machine (or testing server) first, make sure you have all required features running before migrating.

3

Re: Whislist for migration to iRedAdmin-Pro (MySql)

ZhangHuangbin wrote:

Sorry, what do you mean "smtp-callout"?

receipient verfication against an other server either thrue smtp or via LDAP-query
In my test installation (iRedmail free) it works against the local users (when mx=0) but I need it against the relay server for the given domain
When I switch to mx=1 then no receipient verfication is done at all

ZhangHuangbin wrote:

If this works for you on old server, it should work on iRedMai

Yes, ist works with iRedmail.
Unfortunately just for the whole server
I would like to have it on a server/domain/user basis

4

Re: Whislist for migration to iRedAdmin-Pro (MySql)

robert.schuster wrote:

When I switch to mx=1 then no receipient verfication is done at all

You can enable Postfix parameter "relay_recipient_maps" for this purpose, it's almost same as smtpd_sender_login_maps.

robert.schuster wrote:

Yes, ist works with iRedmail.
Unfortunately just for the whole server
I would like to have it on a server/domain/user basis

iRedMail runs Amavisd, it's same as your old server. If you can achieve it with Amavisd on old server, it should work with iRedMail.

5

Re: Whislist for migration to iRedAdmin-Pro (MySql)

It seems you dont understand me:

RELAY PROBLEM:
If I set mx=1 adress verification is switched off completely - I dont want this!

mx=0 verifies all adresses againt the "virtual mailbox table"
This is O.K. for local domains/users which are using roundcube as mailreader

This is not O.K. for relayed domains to another server because I dont want to maintain an extra relaymap. The standard postfix behavior is to verify against the given relay host for this domain (default_transport). Of course this setting can be overruled by a given address_verify_default_transport map. Unfortunately neither the first one nor the other ae functional with iRedmail.
My question is why?

ARCHIVING PROBLEM:
It works with iRedmail!
Again: My question is how to set the "mail is archived" not just for the whole server, but for just a few domains or a single user.
This by the way is not a questionhow to do this, this is a feature request
See the subject: WHISLIST

6

Re: Whislist for migration to iRedAdmin-Pro (MySql)

robert.schuster wrote:

RELAY PROBLEM:
If I set mx=1 adress verification is switched off completely - I dont want this!
mx=0 verifies all adresses againt the "virtual mailbox table"
This is O.K. for local domains/users which are using roundcube as mailreader
This is not O.K. for relayed domains to another server because I dont want to maintain an extra relaymap. The standard postfix behavior is to verify against the given relay host for this domain (default_transport). Of course this setting can be overruled by a given address_verify_default_transport map. Unfortunately neither the first one nor the other ae functional with iRedmail.
My question is why?

If you mark a domain as backup mx (set mx=1), how do you verify all addresses? query 'virtual mailbox table' too?
I don't think Postfix will verify address against the given relay host for this domain, and it should be 'relay_transport', not 'default_transport'. relay_transport is set to 'relay' by default, it doesn't verify address.

I'm still not very clear what you want about this question/wishlist.

robert.schuster wrote:

ARCHIVING PROBLEM:
It works with iRedmail!
Again: My question is how to set the "mail is archived" not just for the whole server, but for just a few domains or a single user.
This by the way is not a questionhow to do this, this is a feature request
See the subject: WHISLIST

Maybe you can try to define your own $policy_bank, then list certain domains/users as member of this $policy_bank.
I didn't try it before, you have to try it yourself, or ask in Amavisd mailing list.